Vote swapping in irresolute two-tier voting procedures - Cnam - Conservatoire national des arts et métiers Access content directly
Journal Articles Social Choice and Welfare Year : 2023

Vote swapping in irresolute two-tier voting procedures


We investigate a specific type of group manipulation in two-tier elections, which involves pairs of voters agreeing to exchange their votes. Two-tier elections are modeled as a two-stage choice procedure. In the first stage, voters are distributed into districts, and district preferences result from aggregating voters’ preferences districtwise through some aggregation rule. Final outcomes are obtained in the second stage by applying a social choice function that outputs one or several alternatives from the profile of district preferences. Combining an aggregation rule and a social choice function defines a constitution. Voter preferences, defined as linear orders, are extended to complete binary relations by means of some extension rule. A constitution is swap-proof w.r.t. a given extension rule if one cannot find pairs of voters who, by exchanging their preferences get better off (w.r.t. their extended preference over sets). We consider four specific extension rules: Nehring, Kelly, Fishburn, and Gärdenfors. We establish sufficient conditions for the swap-proofness of a constitution w.r.t. each extension rule. Special attention is paid to majority constitutions, where both the aggregation rule and the social choice function are based on simple majority voting. We show that swap-proofness for majority constitutions pertains to a specific weakening of group strategy-proofness. Moreover, we characterize swap-proof majority constitutions w.r.t. each extension rule. Finally, we show that no constitution based on scoring methods is swap-proof.
No file

Dates and versions

hal-03958175 , version 1 (26-01-2023)



Hayrullah Dindar, Jean Lainé. Vote swapping in irresolute two-tier voting procedures. Social Choice and Welfare, 2023, ⟨10.1007/s00355-022-01445-z⟩. ⟨hal-03958175⟩
24 View
0 Download



Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More